sports

Celtic a 'hard watch' & 'sensational' Well - fan reaction

Hibernian's first win at Celtic Park since 2010 was the latest twist in the title race [SNS]

Hearst extended their lead at the top of the table, Celtic slumped to what could be a costly defeat, Rangers dropped points on the road and Motherwell shone as they put pressure on the top three.

Just another weekend in what's been a memorable Scottish Premiership season.

With just a handful of games to go until the split, every moment counts and the six fixtures over Saturday and Sunday delivered plenty of storylines, as usual.

BBC Scotland asked for your views on the action through our live pages.

Here is a selection of what you made of a dramatic weekend in the top flight.

'Toothless' Celtic struggle against 'controlled and professional' Hibs

Celtic fans were dismayed by their team's showing in Sunday's 2-1 home defeat by Hibernian...

John: We're not playing well but still clinging on. With Martin O'Neill in charge I'll never give up until it's mathematically impossible. They need to win every game now until the end of the season. Do I think it is possible? I'm not confident but... it's not over yet!

Lewis: That game was a hard watch. Never have I seen so many players who are of a standard so poor for a club of Celtic's stature. The people who run the club are clearly to blame.

Peter: If Martin O'Neill thinks we were terrific he must have been at another match. We were rubbish and got what we deserved. We'll do well to finish third the way we are playing. The core of our team is well past its sell by date and we don't seem to be able to get anyone capable or ready to replace them. Seething.

Harry: Celtic still have 33 points to play for, and are well placed to win the league. Victories over Hearts and Rangers are not beyond the team. A more direct approach is required: stop square-passing and go for goal. Run at defences and beat them. There's no turning back.

Benny: Toothless again from Celtic in the final third of the pitch. No cutting edge and no goal threat. No clue why Trusty let himself be goaded for the red card. Very naive from a player who should know better. How we lost that game is typical of this whole season. Shambolic.

Hibs ended a 16-year wait for a win at Celtic Park and supporters gave credit to head coach David Gray...

Niall: A stunning result and badly needed for this team and manager. Hibs have shown in flashes that they can compete with the best in the league, so let's keep that momentum going until the end of the season. Who knows where we could end up?

Hannah: It's been some two seasons for Sir David Gray. Since he's been in the driving seat at Hibs, the team have won at Celtic Park, Ibrox, Tynecastle and Pittodrie (on more than one occasion). It's been inconsistent but you've got to say Hibs wouldn't have gotten the results they have bagged if Gray wasn't in charge. Build that man a statue.

Scott: At half-time I was thinking 'same old Hibs' but they stuck at it and whilst Celtic huffed and puffed I thought Hibs put on a controlled, professional performance. More like this please.

Tim: It looks like Hibs' transfer business in January was top notch. The new signings are adding a touch of class. And with Nicky Cadden back, we have a real threat. If only we could run a string of good results together.

Alan: Well done Sir David, that proves the doubters wrong. It took Fergie over three years to sort out Manchester United. Hibs are definitely in a much better place after a few dodgy managerial appointments in the recent past. Very organised today, good signs from some of the new recruits, but still think a decent keeper would take us to the next level.

Neil: A great result, I've seen us play better and got beaten. Miguel Chaiwa was a standout, hopefully this run in the team helps him flourish. Everyone is saying the result helps Hearts, but I'm not bothered as we'll skelp them as well.

'Small margins' and 'epic howler' as Rangers draw at Livingston

Rangers dropped two valuable points in the title race and fans were unhappy about a late penalty call that didn't go their way...

John: Rangers threw the kitchen sink at Livingston but it was it was just one of those days unfortunately. On another day it could have been 2-5. Ref's decision not to award a foul/penalty and red card for the late challenge on Mikey Moore was an epic howler. Onwards & upwards. The upcoming Old Firm double header will be pivotal in deciding the honours for season 25-26. I can't wait!

Alan: One of the strangest decisions of the season at the end. It's a foul all day long, only question was inside or outside the box? Small margins cost titles, and this year it's tighter than ever.

Derek: It was proved again today, Chermiti is not the answer! Why couldn't we play with the same intensity that we finished the game with? Far too slow and poor goals to give away from a defensive point of view. No wins in the last three away games, that form doesn't win you leagues. Sorry lads, just not good enough.

Elaine: Not our best but how many times are we going to be on the wrong end of a ridiculous VAR decision. Fair play to the Livi goalkeeper though but his MOTM says it all. Our strikers need to step up if we are going to win the league.

Matthew: A frantic performance categorised by desperate attack and lacklustre defence. Rohl has worked wonders with this squad, but our defensive shape is still at sea every time we face set pieces and counter attacks. Some of these guys earn more every week than I do in a year - surely you can stay focused for a full 90 minutes of a football match. We seem incredulously shot shy, passing backwards or sideways waiting for an open goal or a tap in to present itself. We need another dimension in attack.

Livingston supporters were enjoying the Marvin Bartley effect and starting to believe after a gruelling season so far...

Malky: Gutted. I thought the Lions were going to get a well deserved victory but the ref had other ideas. Definitely an improvement under big Marv.

Malcolm: A good result that probably accurately reflects the game. The forward line does seem to be coming together now, which is brilliant. Seems that we have a huge squad now. Maybe it'd help training and selection if we shed some weight. If the goals start coming we'll at least go down fighting or, at a push, retain our Premiership status. It's a shame though that the mainstream media will now spend a week bubbling about the penalty claim and not mention the Livi goals (the first of which was incredible, and the second a textbook finish). If Rangers can't beat a 10-man Livingston in over 100 minutes, then credit to Livingston. Well done!

Matt: There's little point in asking where that performance has been all season - Marvin has got more of a tune out of that squad in three games than the previous manager did in the last 25. Full credit to Bartley for the impact he's made - he's not only saying the right things to the camera, but clearly implementing them behind the scenes as well. That performance yesterday was the most entertainment we've had at a Livingston game in a very long time - if that continues 'til the end of the season there's a danger Marvin will get the fans believing they can somehow stay up as much as he does!

'Nervous' Hearts do business, Falkirk 'still learning'

Islam Chesnokov
Islam Chesnokov scored the only goal of the game at Tynecastle [BBC]

Results are more important than performances at this stage in the season and Hearts fans admitted it was a tense afternoon as their side defeated Falkirk 1-0 at Tynecastle..

Paul: A win is a win at this point in the season. Being only a goal up was pretty nerve shredding, but in the end it was reasonably comfortable.

Jim: It was a hard, nervous watch at times and not pretty, but it's three points in the bag and at this stage that's all that counts. Injuries continue to be a concern and the sooner we get Lawrence Shankland and Cammy Devlin back the better.

Peter: We saw a lot of character in our side with great contributions from Blair Spittal, Harry Milne and the tireless Claudio Braga. Islam Chesnokov stepped up his game and the finish for his first Hearts goal was clinical. We need to start games better, but well done overall in a tense affair.

Harry: Braga single-handedly keeping us in this. His work off the ball is all so selfless and he's doing the work of two men. He's crying out for Shankland, we are missing that touch of quality in that gap.

Frank: This is the type of result which, in the past, the Old Firm grind out on their way to first or second, so that is a positive for us. Falkirk will go home regretting their inability to score.

Neil: Hearts starting to look tired and nervous as we approach the business end of the season. Goes without saying that we miss Devlin and Shankland badly. Midfield replacements not good enough and Braga being asked to do a job that takes him away from his comfort zone. Chesnokov not yet up to speed but starting to show promising signs. One more game ticked off - 10 to go to become legends!

Despite defeat, Falkirk could hold their heads high after another strong showing...

Dave: Falkirk have come a long way in a short time under McGlynn. We are young and we are still learning to go to league leaders lose by odd goal. We will come again.

'Sweet revenge' for five-star Motherwell in Paisley rout

Motherwell enjoyed a statement win in Paisley with a 5-0 demolition of St Mirren that keeps their Premiership title hopes alive...

Matt: That was sweet revenge for the League Cup semi-final defeat. We were electric. Now we just need to repeat the feat against Dundee and Dundee United and it gives us a fantastic platform to take into the Celtic game at Parkhead. Win that and we are firmly in the title race. Have to pinch myself that we are even in the conversation.

Mark: Sensational Motherwell do it again! How many teams can go to St Mirren's home turf and batter them for five goals? I don't want to get carried away, but that is a champions performance- too soon?

Alan: The manager has had a transformational impact on Motherwell and this was another comprehensive and utterly impressive result. It's particularly pleasing to have another clean sheet. The defence need as much praise as the attack, and with a number of different scorers the issue of having no striker a few months ago has surely been put to rest.

Robert: Five goals and another clean sheet is another fantastic result. And five different scorers is very encouraging.

James: Phenomenal. No more words required. On we go. Have said for long enough we would give somebody a doing.

Edward: We are title contenders!

St Mirren fans were unhappy with Stephen Robinson's tactical switch and another poor performance that has fears of relegation growing by the day...

Eddie: We haven't performed since winning the cup. It's a worry given the total collapse against Well (another shocking ref decision albeit game was over by then). We seem to have become a bad team in two months and we are staring at relegation.

Andrew: It seems crazy that Stephen Robinson tried out four at the back against such a good team. Surely we need to get back to a solid 3-5-2 with Gogic at the back, Richardson right-wing back and Mandron and Nlundulu up front. The constant changing of personnel (and Richard King getting a game) is why we keep shipping goals. If we don't go back to our reliable first XI we will be relegated.

William: Totally embarrassing defeat. How can the coach set up like that with the 11 he put on the park, they were miles off it. Recruitment, especially in January, has been terrible. Defeat to Livingston and we might not escape with a play-off.

John: I keep thinking that we've reached rock bottom, but this St Mirren side keeps proving me wrong. A horrendous performance from start to finish, with every part of the side lacking confidence and competence. We were lucky it was only five. Last night exposed how threadbare the squad is at the moment. Also that Robbo's tactics aren't going to get us out of this mess.

Peter: The manager has admitted his error in playing a back four. As for the red card, everyone can see it's a ridiculous decision by the officials and the untouched Motherwell player.

Douglas: Difficult to think where to start with this performance. Shamal George had a shocker, but in truth there were hardly any creditable performances out there. Saints, on the basis of this dismal performance, are in real trouble.

'Dire' Dons slip to defeat against 'unbelievable' Dundee

Dundee's Ethan Hamilton scores against Aberdeen
Ethan Hamilton's stunning strike settled the contest at Pittodrie [SNS]

Dundee won at Pittodrie in the top flight for the first time in 22 years by beating 10-man Aberdeen 3-2 and the Dons support was furious...

James: Excuses. Poor discipline. Non-progressive. Fearful. Tired. No confidence. Poor defensively. Lack of intensity. No backbone and grit. Aberdeen need to sit back and really evaluate the direction the club is going. Large financial commitments have been made with transfer fees and wage structure... and it is getting worse, not better.

Mike: Things usually get worse before they get better and this is what we are seeing. Not sure the club can wait until the summer, though, if results don't improve as all the uncertainty is having a psychological impact on everyone including the coaches. Any potential manager humming and hawing like Eirik Horneland should be deleted from the list and move on. Another example of poor leadership at the top.

Sandy: Dire, dismal, dreich. I am not talking about the weather. Forget about this so-called frontrunner for the manager's job. If he can't come now, get someone else in the door. Who is in charge, the club or this so called frontrunner?

Neil: This season has transpired as the worst in my 50-plus years supporting the club. There have been far too many mediocre players signed, too many in on loan and general apathy in footballers playing for the badge. Ultimately, the club owners need to come out and speak to the many fans who still attend matches to explain how they plan to turn this around.

Chris: Useless, clueless, heartless - any of these cover how the team perform week on week. Time for the fans to vote with their feet and stay away till change comes.

Mark: Garbage again and the same old excuses about defending and refereeing decisions. So poor from Aberdeen and time for a clearout from boardroom level to playing staff. Nothing positive can be taken from this season.

Dundee have made a habit of breaking long-standing records under Steven Pressley this season and fans are delighted at what they are seeing...

Flynn: Another record broken by Pressley, outstanding performance again but this time a result to merit it. Past Dundee teams would give up after going 1-0 down but for once Dundee didn't give up and deserved all three points. Another great performance from Ethan Hamilton and the only issue will be keeping him in the summer.

Darren: Great win, but Jon McCracken at fault again, he has cost us goals in the last three games. He made the same mistake as last week but fortunately we were not punished on this occasion.

Jim: Absolutely brilliant result. The players showed fight to get the win and proved that they can win games after setbacks. And what a winner as well. We've been playing well without getting results and we needed that. With four difficult games coming up Steven Pressley may have to look at McCracken's position. He's made mistakes in a lot of games.

Gary: 22 years! Another stat this team have binned! After the mistake for the first goal and slow second-half start I feared the usual dropped points, but what a cracker from one of our captains! Still think the keeper needs swapped out and we could use our bench better, but can't really argue with the quality of the winning goal.

Mark: Beyond words, unbelievable result.

Albert: Fantastic to see Pressley's great work coming to fruition now. A long-awaited victory up at Pittodrie too. Future looks bright again.

'Jellyfish' United fail to impress as Kilmarnock take 'priceless' point

On a pitch that has taken a toll from recent rain, United held the lead through Amar Fatah but fans were dismayed as Kilmarnock snatched a 1-1 draw with an added-time goal...

Das: Controlled the midfield for 85 minutes, then for some reason switched off. Why Jim Goodwin never killed the play with two subs, I have no idea.

Dave: Yet another pathetic defensive display at the end. This bunch of players look like a jellyfish looking for a backbone. Ross Graham as captain? Don't make me laugh! He is a bog standard defender totally out of his depth in a leadership role.

Ross: Mentality, mentality, mentality. Home league form has been horrible but we still don't learn. We sat back deep in numbers because that always works. Not. Invited the goal and just once again looked soft. Stop pressing the panic button, United.

Euan: Once again we let teams attack us by sitting back in and around our box for the last 10 minutes. Every United supporter saw it coming. What does Jim do? He stands there and watches and does nothing and then blames the players post-match. How many times does this have to happen before he realises he's the one at fault? Time's up, Jim. Move on and please do it quickly.

Andrew: Goodwin playing to hang on was the issue when we have consistently let in late goals all season. Last 10 we didn't have any possession and needed fresh legs, didn't make any subs. That's on Jim.

Matthew: That result is 100% on the manager. Everyone in the ground could see how deep the team was and that subs needed made with five minutes to go - why couldn't he? A decent team performance sabotaged by Goodwin's poor game management.

Kilmarnock fans were impressed by the attitude shown by Neil McCann's side and took positives from edging another point closer to St Mirren...

Robert: Kelle Roos was outstanding, their goal was from skill not a mistake and we kept going to the end. It was good to have Marley Watkins back. Definitely think the red for Jack Thomson was only a yellow, not the last man.

Amy: A deserved point in the end. We've got a much more exciting style of play now and actually look like we can score goals. Positive we'll have enough to catch St Mirren, who've yet to beat us in the league.

John: I hope the team gets back to winning ways soon as we need more wins than draws. Hope we can keep David Watson, sign him up soon so that we can get a fair transfer price for him.

Frank: A point gained on a difficult pitch can only be positive. Not losing while not playing as well as previous games is also a positive. The team certainly rolled their sleeves up and gave a honest account of themselves.

Anna: Well, it makes a change for us to score in injury time instead of being scored against. One goal was always going to decide the game... or so it seemed until Watkins popped up with a priceless equaliser. My only criticism is why did we start Aaron Tshibola up front when there were proven strikers like Bruce Anderson and Watkins on the bench? Still, a priceless away point like that is always welcome.

Read full story at Yahoo Sport →