This is not a love letter. It’s more of a like letter.
Among Green Bay Packers fans, tight end Luke Musgrave has been a bit of a punching bag. He’s the guy who “falls down after every catch,” the draft pick forever tied to Tucker Kraft. And in that comparison, Musgrave loses every time.
But I’m not here to compare Musgrave to Kraft. I’m here, humbly — a simple man who enjoys rooting for tight ends — to say that the Packers could do a lot worse for a number two tight end.
Statistically, Musgrave’s 2025 season looks a lot like what other solid second tight ends around the league produce. Roughly two dozen catches, around 250 yards, zero or maybe one score — numbers that land him in the same neighborhood as players like Tommy Tremble, Jeremy Ruckert, or Austin Hooper in similar(ish) roles. None of those guys are featured weapons. All of them are functional pieces. At this point, that’s his job.
Musgrave remains a tremendous athlete who can run real routes, stretch a seam once in a while, and keep defenses from ignoring half the formation. Pressed into duty after Tucker Kraft suffered a season-ending injury, all Musgrave did was exactly what he was told while averaging 10.5 yards per catch. Not bad! Not elite, but not bad!
Yes, he goes down quickly sometimes (or often). Yes, Kraft is more productive (and more fun to watch). And yes expectations on him have been very high. But that’s not his fault. He’s not broken. He’s just a complementary player doing complementary things.
I like you, Luke Musgrave.
Tight end is a sneaky Packers draft need– Luke Musgrave stepped up admirably for an injured Tucker Kraft in 2025, but should the Packers bring in fresh blood at the position?
Why Detroit Lions should target Packers tight end John FitzPatrick – Tight end John FitzPatrick can thrive with the Detroit Lions. Here’s why.
Romeo Doubs to the Eagles? – The Philadelphia Eagles need to take a look at the wide receiver room as a whole. Could they target Doubs?
Two free agency moves the Packers should make – Here’s a few moves the Packers could make to help them finally get over the hump.
LISTEN: Is the Packers beat doing a good job? – Jon Meerdink gives his perspective on the Packers beat, and how well they’re serving, or not serving, the fans.