Top 10 Foolish NFL Draft Picks of the Past Decade

The list spotlights ten draft decisions that, at the time, seemed off base and later proved even more costly. The Buccaneers’ 2016 move to trade up for kicker Roberto Aguayo, who converted only 22 of 31 field goals and was waived the following year, ranks among the most glaring blunders. In 2023, the Commanders drafted cornerback Emmanuel Forbes Jr. over Christian Gonzalez, a decision that saw Forbes benched midway through his rookie season due to size and tackling concerns.

These picks illustrate how even seasoned general managers can misjudge talent, leading to embarrassment and roster instability. The full list offers a cautionary look at the pitfalls of draft strategy in the NFL.